What rights should animals be given? Where do we draw the line between abuse, caring, pampering, and neglect? This question is ongoing and has been answered in many different ways throughout history.
In Peter Singer's point of view....
Animal Mistreatment = Slavery
Animal Rights = Human Rights
Human Rights = Equal opportunity + No cruel or unusual punishment + Care and Attention
Human Suffering = Animal Suffering
Proper Animal Treatment = No Unnecessary Suffering
Therefore....
Animals = Humans
Eating Animals = Eating Humans
Eating Animals = Wrong = Eating Humans
Vegetarianism = Good
Animal Testing = Human Testing
Animal Pets = Human Pets
Euthanasia = Capital Punishment
Humans eating animals = Animals eating humans
Human progress = Evil
In Vicki Hearne's point of view....
Relationship = Mutual Trust
Animal + Human = Relationship
Happiness = Good
Relationship = Good
Suffering = Not Important
Therefore....
Pets = Good
Humans Treat Animals = Animals Treat Humans
Relationship = Happiness
Human Happiness = Animal Happiness
Different Relationship = Different Rights
Different Animal = Different Relationship
Animal Rights = ?
Both Author's ideas of animal rights are very odd. Singer's view is extreme and very impractical but Hearne's is very ambiguous and not very relevant when it comes to the rights of animals.
In my opinion, animals have rights but they are very different than the rights of humans. Humans should be able to consume animals as much as they like, but our methods of raising animals should be more natural and less manipulative. Also, animal testing should be allowed because if we weren't to test on animals, who would we test on, humans? Even though animals may suffer in the process, it is our nature as humans to protect our own species. In the wild animals generally protect and foster the growth of their own species without nearly as much regard to others, so who is to say humans shouldn't be the same way? Our first responsibility is to ourselves, but when it comes to animal treatment, we should be a little more conscious of our actions and reduce suffering as much as possible and use as few animals as possible.